Why dieting made us fat: On weight loss, metabolism and why food is not the enemy

Published on March 31, 2026

In a world consumed and quick-fix solutions, the conversation around weight loss and metabolism has become increasingly complex. Renowned nutritionist Rujuta Diwekar recently sat down with Shonali Muthalaly to unravel the myths surrounding dieting and advocate for a balanced approach to eating that reinstates joy rather than fear.

The prevailing narrative often blames food for weight gain, categorizing it in either good or bad camps. However, Diwekar argues that this binary view is not only misleading but detrimental to our relationship with food. “Food is not the enemy,” she asserts, highlighting that it is often our misguided perceptions about food and dieting that lead to unhealthy lifestyle choices.

One pervasive myth Diwekar addresses is the idea that dieting is a reliable solution for weight loss. She notes that many individuals experience initial success on restrictive diets, only to find themselves gaining back the weight, often with extra pounds added. This rebound effect can be attributed to the body’s metabolic response to deprivation. When calories are drastically cut, the body goes into conservation mode, slowing down metabolism to preserve energy, ultimately making weight loss more challenging in the long run.

Muthalaly raises the issue of societal pressures that enforce strict standards for body image, often pushing individuals to extremes. Diwekar acknowledges that while changing the narrative around health and body size is essential, it requires a cultural shift in how we view food. She encourages a commonsense approach where individuals are empowered to listen to their bodies, trust their hunger cues, and make choices that nourish rather than restrict.

The conversation also emphasizes the importance of understanding individual needs. What works for one person might not work for another, and this variability should be embraced rather than ignored. Diwekar suggests adopting a holistic perspective that incorporates physical activity, mental well-being, and overall lifestyle rather than fixating solely on weight.

Furthermore, Diwekar advocates for a return to traditional eating practices, which often emphasize balanced meals made from whole ingredients. and locally sourced foods while enjoying them fully and joyfully, individuals can create sustainable habits without the stress of calorie counting or guilt.

As the discussion unfolds, it becomes clear that the fight against diet culture is just beginning. focus from rigid dieting to a more balanced understanding of food, we can nurture a healthier relationship with eating that fosters both physical and emotional well-being.

In the end, the message is clear: it’s time to dismantle the myths surrounding dieting, metabolism, and food. A reassessment of our approaches can lead to a more liberated and balanced way of nurturing our bodies, paving the way for a healthier future that embraces the complexities of human experiences with food.

Related News