Why dieting made us fat: On weight loss, metabolism and why food is not the enemy

Published on March 22, 2026

In a world increasingly obsessed with diet culture and quick-fix solutions to weight loss, the conversation led Diwekar with journalist Shonali Muthalaly sheds light on a critical misunderstanding: dieting may actually contribute to weight gain and metabolic dysfunction. Their discussion emphasizes that food is not the adversary it is often portrayed to be; rather, our approach and mindset towards it are pivotal in achieving a healthier relationship with food.

Diwekar begins myths surrounding metabolism. Many believe that to lose weight, one must adhere to restrictive diets that drastically cut calories. However, such practices can lead to a slower metabolism as the body adapts to starvation conditions. This metabolic slowdown often results in regaining more weight once normal eating patterns resume, creating a vicious cycle of dieting and weight fluctuations.

The conversation highlights the importance of understanding individual metabolic needs based on genetics, lifestyle, and daily activity levels. Diwekar encourages a shift away from the one-size-fits-all mentality that dominates diet culture to a more intuitive approach that considers personal dietary preferences and cultural practices. This is a call to embrace whole foods and traditional dietary habits that have sustained populations for generations.

Diwekar and Muthalaly discuss the concept of “dieting fatigue,” a state of emotional and physical exhaustion that arises from constant calorie counting and meal restrictions. Instead of focusing on elimination, Diwekar advocates for incorporating diverse foods that nourish the body, emphasizing balance over deprivation. This commonsense approach fosters a healthier mindset, allowing individuals to enjoy a variety of foods without guilt.

Moreover, they explore the psychological aspects of dieting, pointing out how restrictive eating can lead to unhealthy relationships with food. When foods are labeled as “bad” or “good,” it can trigger a cycle of guilt and shame that ultimately detracts from overall well-being. Diwekar suggests that fostering a positive relationship with food involves recognizing it as a source of joy and nourishment, rather than as something to fear or obsess over.

The conversation also touches on the societal pressures and unrealistic standards often perpetuated influencers, which can skew perceptions of health and body image. Diwekar urges listeners to redefine health in terms of well-being rather than appearance, emphasizing physical and mental health as paramount.

In conclusion, the discussion between Diwekar and Muthalaly invites a reevaluation of our approach to eating. Recognizing that sustainable weight management is not about short-term restrictions but rather about nourishing the body in a balanced way can fundamentally change how we view our health. Embracing food as a friend rather than an enemy sets the foundation for a lifelong journey of wellness, resilience, and self-acceptance. The path forward is clear: it’s time to move beyond diet culture and cultivate a healthy, harmonious relationship with food.